Nenzing Nursing Home / Dietger Wissounig Architects. photo copyright Albrecht Imanuel Schnabel
Ireland is edging closer and closer to making our buildings more energy efficient with new Building Regulations becoming incrementally better as time goes on. Time will tell whether this is the correct approach as the IPCC Special Report on 1.5 °C shows that we need drastic reductions urgently.
Despite certain local authorities’ efforts in Ireland to bravely take the lead over national government’s failure to regulate buildings appropriately, (Dublin City Council, Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council), Ireland’s general Building Regulations remain at ‘Nearly Zero Energy Building’ standard, this is about half as efficient as a passive building, and costs the same.
INCREMENTAL IMPROVEMENTS CREATE REDUNDANCY
Incremental Building Regulation improvements are the government’s way of trying to do the right thing without damaging an industry which is price sensitive. By gradually improving building standards, the cost of building energy efficient buildings is supposed to be acceptable to the once-strong CIF lobby.
From a design and certification industry point of view, incremental improvements are an economic disaster. Every few years, the designers and inspectors of buildings have to re-learn how to make buildings, details have to be re-invented, people re-trained, new products developed and systems changed, with all the inertia and redundancy that entails. Then, do this in a dysfunctional market with turmoil and loss of intellectual depth through emigration etc. and we have the current situation with little change towards sustainable buildings.
MAKING CERTAIN SECTORS PASSIVE FIRST
Balancing stability in the market with the need to improve practices is a tricky juggling-act for the government. The answer might be the it would be vastly more effective to segment the industry. Divide-and-conquer. Allow certain sectors to move straight to the end-game. (This has already happened to private house building, where everyone wants a passive house, rather than the legal minimum energy standard).
By this, I mean, regulate that certain uses, must now be passive. This should start with buildings with the highest space heat demand, and with the highest demand for thermal comfort and high energy-costs. This buildings would benefit most from the improved performance. Also, by making it sectoral, it would ensure the playing field is level for competing operators and investors.
The cost of achieving this would be negligible, as designers tend to be sectorally specific also. So a handful of teams could up-skill once, and continue to serve their market.
The beauty of it though, is that the government would incrementally be supporting the already expanding passive construction sector, allowing it to gradually replace unacceptable building practices. As the practice becomes the norm in a sector and the benefits established, the government can add another building type, most suitable to the standard, to the prescribed passive performance level.
NURSING HOMES FIRST SECTOR TO GO PASSIVE
Passive buildings are very stable in terms of temperature, have no cold spots or draughts. It is easy to heat them. Private residential buildings have a long history of passive construction. Nursing homes for the elderly are a very similar building type. But critically, the elderly tend to have specific comfort needs relative to the general population.
There is research that shows, variations in comfort conditions for people with dementia increases agitation (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28429641).
Even those without dementia issues, tend to like higher temperatures than the general population. People with poorer circulation, struggle to regulate their own body temperature. Regulation of body temperature is central to our ability to fight infection.
This is true in relation to overheating as well as winter comfort. The elderly are less able to cope with heat waves, again a well designed passive building will stay cool in Summer.
This has already been achieved by Garry & Norma Gavigan in their extension to Glenashling Nursing Home in Celbridge built to the PassivHaus standard.
Maybe it is time the Nursing home industry united with the construction industry, and lobby the government together to take a brave step to creating great outcomes for their residents, and a safe future for their grandchildren.
THANK YOU FOR READING OUR BLOG POST ON HOW BUILDING REGULATIONS PART L COULD BE BETTER FOR NURSING HOMES
I would love to hear your comments on the cost plan and if you have any questions post them in the comments below and I will get back to you. Thank you for reading my blog on this issue and do share it using the buttons opposite!
If you would like to speak with an architect please feel free to Contact Us
Also you can leave a comment or question below.
Ask The Expert!
You are invited to post your questions on this topic in the comment section at the end of the page and we will advise you as best we can….
PLEASE COME TO THE 2018 CAA EXHIBITION GALA OPENING ON FRIDAY 9TH NOVEMBER 2018 7 P.M.! We are delighted that our project, St Joseph's Woolen Mills in Castlemartyr has been selected by the CAA jury for this exhibition and would like to invite all our friends,...
How to plan for developing your site in Cork for small infill developments. There is huge potential locked up in under-developed sites in all over the city. With the huge pressure to get houses built, there is a great opportunity for those sites to yield much needed...
The single most important thing to do if you want your house build to go as smoothly as possible, is get a realistic budget in place before you start designing. A budget is not what you want to spend, that is just a notional figure of what funds you think you can live...
#ArchitalksIE This is my first contribution to a shared discussion among architects practicing in Ireland, where we will discuss aspects of our services and the profession, under the Twitter hastag #ArchitalksIE By using this hashtag on twitter, or links provided...
Cork Architects selected for 2018 CAA Annual Exhibition The Jury of the Cork Architectural Association met on Friday 7th September and reviewed the submissions from Cork Architectural practices entered for the upcoming Exhibition. This year there will be a significant...
Passive House Architecture Talk in Clonmel The PassivHaus architecture Company is delighted to be asked by Tipperary County Museum to talk to the people of Tipperary on Passive House Architecture. We will be focusing on the RIAI Award winning Quirke's Pharmacy...
Paul McNally architect, passivhaus expert, director of the PassivHaus Architecture Company based in Cork, Ireland. Designer of...
Rural Passive House design for 2018 This is our latest passive house project about to be submitted for planning approval in early 2018. On the edge of a town in County Cork, nestled in a beautiful valley with stunning views. The design orients the main dining room...
New Passive House Office Building Project For further information see The PassivHaus Architecture Company project page here! Call us on 021 2429455 if you would like something...
Thermal Bridge assessment for Part L compliance It seems a shame that due to restriction of competence to calculate thermal bridges for Part L compliance to only registered assessors, that it is very unlikely that these calculations will be carried out at all. There...